Three Sectors, Three Missing Numbers: Kenya's Policy Runs on Figures Nobody Has PublishedThree Sectors, Three Missing Numbers: Kenya's Policy Runs on Figures Nobody Has Published
Key Highlights
- Kenya is setting prices and jobs targets in coffee, kerosene and call centres without publishing the one number each of them rests on.
- A promised 500,000 call centre jobs is about 14 times today's workforce, while the sector's own forecast supports roughly 85,000.
- Mwenendo argues every proposal should arrive with its own numbers, or admit plainly which ones are missing.
A policy is only as honest as the number it rests on, and across three sectors Kenya's most important numbers are the ones nobody has published. Coffee has no national farmgate figure. Kerosene has no price build-up. Call centres have a jobs target that the industry's own sums cannot reach.
That is not a run of coincidences. It is a habit, and it lets officials and companies argue about conclusions without ever showing the arithmetic. Mwenendo's position is that no price, levy or jobs target should be announced without a published schedule of the figures behind it, or an honest statement of which figures do not exist.
Coffee Counts the Auction and Forgets the Farmer
Take the headline from the coffee year to September. Auction sales brought in KSh 41B ($315.60M), a rise of 15.2%, yet the quantity sold grew almost as fast, by 14.3%. Mwenendo's analysis of the coffee year read that as more bags, not better prices. Two brokers handled about 47% of the volume.
What is missing is the only number that matters to a smallholder: how much of the KSh 41B reached the farmer. Mwenendo's editorial on the coffee year found no published national figure for it. A revival is being announced on the strength of the total, and the total cannot tell a good year from a good year for brokers.
Kerosene Rose Twice as Fast at the Pump
Households that cook and light their homes with kerosene have been hit by a pump increase of KSh 28.49 ($0.22) a litre. Landed import costs rose by only KSh 12.25 ($0.09), as Mwenendo's editorial on kerosene prices recorded. The Energy and Petroleum Regulatory Authority pointed to the end of a subsidy.
The explanation may be right. Nobody can check it, because no product-by-product build-up has been published. A household cannot tell how much of the extra KSh 16.24 ($0.12) a litre is subsidy, tax or margin. The number that would settle it exists inside the pricing formula, and it has not been shown to the people paying it.
A Jobs Target Fourteen Times the Workforce
Kenya has been named the cheapest English-speaking call centre location among 18 countries, and the headline promise is 500,000 jobs. Mwenendo's analysis of the call centre sums found today's workforce at about 36,000, so the target is roughly 14 times the industry as it stands.
Invest Kenya's sector pack puts agent pay at KSh 32,700 ($252) a month and base-case 2030 revenue at 2.4 times today's. Scale today's workforce by that multiple and the result is about 85,000 jobs, not 500,000. The figures suggest the target is an aspiration that was never reconciled with the forecast beneath it.
The Best Case for Announcing Before Counting
The fair defence is that governments cannot wait for perfect data. Surveys cost money, firms guard commercial secrets and a target is meant to stretch. A kerosene review delayed for a full cost audit could leave households guessing for another month.
That defence has force, and it argues for ranges, not silence. A published range, such as 36,000 workers today against a 500,000 goal, tells the reader how far apart claim and evidence sit. What fails the public is the confident announcement that hides the gap, as when a jobs target stands without the forecast beside it.
One Rule for Every Proposal
Mwenendo's proposal is deliberately small. Every ministry, regulator and state agency that announces a price, levy or target should publish, on the day, a one-page schedule of the figures it rests on, the source of each and a plain list of the numbers it does not have.
The National Treasury should adopt the rule for anything that touches tax or spending, EPRA for every price review, and Parliament should ask for the schedule before it debates any proposal. A schedule with gaps would still be an advance on a press release with none.
The cost is a few hours of an officer's time. The cost of the habit it replaces is paid by the coffee farmer, the cooking-fuel household and the graduate waiting for a job that the arithmetic says will not exist.
In Summary
- Who should act?
- The National Treasury, EPRA and other regulators, with Parliament asking for the schedule before it debates any proposal.
- What is the argument?
- Coffee, kerosene and call centres each rest on a number nobody has published: farmgate pay, a price build-up and a jobs forecast.
- When should the figures appear?
- On the day any price, floor, levy or target is announced.
- Where does the gap show?
- In Kenya's coffee auctions, kerosene pricing and the call centre industry.
- Why does it matter?
- A 500,000-job call centre target is about 14 times today's 36,000 workforce, and kerosene's pump rise was more than double its import rise.
- What does Mwenendo propose?
- A one-page schedule of figures, sources and known gaps published with every proposal.