All news
african-markets
10 November 2026· By Mwenendo

Nigerian Insurance Stocks Slide 13.64% This Year as Profits Surge and Share Issues Weigh

Key Highlights

  • Nigeria's insurance stocks are the only major sector in the red this year, even as most large underwriters report sharply higher profits.
  • Fresh capital raising and weak cash conversion explain much of the caution, according to the latest market review.
  • Full-year results early next year will show whether the profit growth turns into dividends for shareholders.

Nigerian insurance shares have fallen 13.64% so far in 2026, making them the only major sector on the Nigerian Exchange in negative territory, even as five of the six largest listed underwriters grew profit by 25% to 80%, according to a Nairametrics market review published on 10 November.

Nigerian Insurance Stocks Slide 13.64% This Year as Profits Surge and Share Issues Weigh

The gap between earnings and prices matters to Kenyan investors who hold or watch Nigerian assets, because it shows how quickly share issues and weak cash flow can overwhelm strong headline profits. The Insurance Index lost 5.52% in October alone.

A sector out of step with the market

Over the same period, the banking index has gained about 60%, the oil and gas index 128% and the All-Share Index about 60%. In 2025, insurance stocks returned about 66%, against 51% for the All-Share Index, so the sector has swung from leader to laggard within a year.

The market has been moving sharply in recent weeks. Mwenendo reported earlier that Dangote Cement surged in October while banking stocks dragged.

Profits are up, prices are not

AIICO Insurance reported a 27% rise in nine-month pre-tax profit, to N19.4 billion (about KSh 1.87B or $14.37M at N1,350 per dollar). Its shares fell 6.6% on the results day and are about 6% lower this year.

AXA Mansard's profit after tax rose 81% to N10.9 billion (about KSh 1.05B or $8.07M), more than double its own forecast. Its stock is about 15% lower since the start of the year. Coronation Insurance reported a 71% rise in profit, yet its shares are roughly a third lower.

NEM Insurance earned N26.8 billion in nine months (about KSh 2.58B or $19.85M), more than its full-year 2025 total. Custodian Investment grew nine-month pre-tax profit by 26%, and its shares are up about 50% this year, one of the few exceptions.

Why investors are cautious

The first concern is dilution. The Nigerian Insurance Industry Reform Act 2025 required insurers to meet new minimum capital levels by July 2026, and the regulator says 43 insurers and reinsurers complied, many by issuing shares. Coronation's share count rose by almost a fifth after it raised N9.2 billion (about KSh 885M or $6.81M). AXA Mansard shareholders approved a rights issue of up to N18.3 billion (about KSh 1.76B or $13.56M), roughly a sixth of its market value.

The second is earnings quality. Much of the profit growth came from investment income rather than underwriting, and AIICO's underwriting margin slipped to about 8%. Reinsurance costs and foreign-exchange losses also rose at several insurers.

The third is cash conversion. NEM's operating cash flow swung to an outflow of N1.1 billion from an inflow of N10.3 billion, as premiums receivable climbed from under N100 million to N9.5 billion. Custodian's operating cash flow also turned negative, which the review attributes probably to consolidating a merchant bank.

Valuations look low

On annualised nine-month earnings, AIICO trades at about 5.6 times earnings, Custodian at 5.9, AXA Mansard at 7.2 and NEM at 7.9. Annualised return on equity ranges from about 13% at Cornerstone to nearly 38% at NEM.

Dividends are thin. Cornerstone offers the highest yield among large insurers at about 6%, Custodian about 4%, while Coronation has not paid and AXA Mansard paid nothing in 2026. Full-year results due early next year will show whether the enlarged share bases still support payouts and whether receivables turn into cash.

Currency conversions use the naira rate of N1,350.45 per dollar reported on 5 November, as covered in Mwenendo's naira report, and are approximate.

#Nigeria
#insurance
#NGX
#AIICO
#AXA Mansard
#NEM Insurance

In Summary

Who is affected?
Investors in listed Nigerian insurers such as AIICO, AXA Mansard, Coronation, NEM and Custodian.
What happened?
The Insurance Index fell 5.52% in October and is down 13.64% year to date, the only major sector index in the red.
When?
Figures cover the year to October 2026 and nine-month results, reviewed on 10 November 2026.
Where?
The Nigerian Exchange, Lagos.
Why are investors cautious?
Share issues to meet new capital rules dilute holders, profit leans on investment income, and some insurers show weak cash conversion.
How will it be tested?
Full-year results due early next year will show dividends on enlarged share bases and whether receivables turn into cash.
AI images used for illustration purposes. All news and stories are factual.
Banking Sell-Off: Nigerian Stocks Lose KSh 68.06B ($525.55M) as NGX All-Share Index Slips 0.44%

Up next

african-markets

Banking Sell-Off: Nigerian Stocks Lose KSh 68.06B ($525.55M) as NGX All-Share Index Slips 0.44%

Profit-taking in Nigeria's biggest lenders snapped a winning streak and pulled the benchmark index back below 253,000 points.

Read next story

More from african-markets

See all

Latest from Mwenendo