All news
african-business
16 November 2026· By Mwenendo

950 Tenants Rank Security Below Rent in South Africa's Commercial Property Market

Key Highlights

  • A 950-person tenant survey shows security matters, but rent and operating costs dominate South Africa's commercial property pressures.
  • Office tenants report the highest security concern at 14%, against 12% in industrial and 10% in retail and mixed-use premises.
  • Recent mass shootings have sharpened the debate, but available data do not show a direct effect on property values.

Security is part of the cost of occupying commercial property in South Africa, but it is not the pressure most tenants put first. A 2026 survey of 950 commercial occupiers by TPN from MRI Software found that 8% cited security concerns among their leading premises challenges, compared with 32% who cited high rental costs and 14% who pointed to high operating costs.

AI-generated illustrative image of a security guard outside a modern South African commercial property at dusk.

The findings offer a measured starting point for a question brought into sharper focus by the two mass shootings that killed 17 people near Pretoria and Pietermaritzburg on 15 November. Police had not established the motives or any link between the separate attacks in their updates the following day. The incidents are a grave public-safety concern, but they do not by themselves prove that commercial property values or investment flows have changed.

Mwenendo's breaking report on the two shootings sets out what police had confirmed. The property question requires a different evidence base: tenant costs, insurance terms, local crime patterns, vacancies, rents and completed transactions.

Security matters differently across property types

The TPN from MRI Software survey found that security concerns were reported by about 10% of retail and mixed-use tenants, 12% of industrial tenants and 14% of office tenants. The report surveyed occupiers across retail, office, industrial and mixed-use premises.

The sector differences matter. Retail properties depend on customers reaching and moving safely through public-facing spaces. Industrial sites may have large perimeters, equipment and goods that need protection. Office tenants may be more concerned about staff access, parking and the safety of employees travelling to and from work. These are possible reasons for different exposures, not explanations proven by the survey.

Security was not the only non-rental issue. Tenants also cited electricity supply and load-shedding concerns, poor infrastructure, access to customers and municipal service delivery. The report found that these operating conditions affect business continuity and may require additional resources from occupiers.

The wider cost pressure is still rent and operations

The survey's ranking is important for landlords and investors because it shows that security competes with affordability for tenants' attention. High rental costs were cited by 32% of respondents and high operating costs by 14%. Electricity supply was cited by 9%, while poor infrastructure maintenance and security concerns each accounted for 8% of the challenges reported across all sectors.

Tenant finances are also under strain. The report found that 42% of respondents said their business performance had declined over the previous year, while 29% reported growth. On lease renewals, 54% said they were likely or very likely to renew, 27% were undecided and 19% were unlikely or very unlikely to renew.

Those figures do not establish that crime is causing tenants to leave. They do show why landlords need to understand the combined cost of rent, utilities, maintenance and security before setting lease terms or planning upgrades.

What crime statistics can and cannot tell investors

The latest available national police figures for April to June 2026 showed 5,427 murders, down 5.9% from the same quarter a year earlier. Robbery at non-residential premises, which includes business robbery, fell by 11.8%. Truck hijacking declined by 21% and carjacking by 18.2%, according to the first-quarter crime figures published by SAnews.

The figures are national and pre-date the November shootings. They cannot show whether a particular office park, shopping centre or industrial estate is safe, and they do not measure the effect of the latest attacks on rents or property prices.

In his 28 August crime-statistics address, Police Minister Firoz Cachalia said crime was concentrated in a relatively small number of precincts.

The government prioritised 140 high-crime precincts for targeted operational support, stronger oversight and improved resource allocation, with a focus on crime intelligence, detective services and action against organised crime, extortion, illegal mining and gang-related violence.

The property risk is measured site by site

For landlords, the practical costs may include security staff, lighting, cameras, access controls, perimeter protection and insurance. Tenants may face disruption, staff-safety concerns and higher operating costs. Insurers and lenders may scrutinise the risk profile of individual properties. The size of those costs has to be established through actual budgets, policy terms and lease negotiations; the survey does not quantify them.

Investors should therefore examine local crime data and police response around each asset, alongside security expenditure, insurance premiums, tenant retention, vacancies and comparable property transactions. A national crime decline does not remove local exposure, just as two shocking attacks do not establish a market-wide property discount.

The survey's message is not that security is irrelevant. It is that security sits within a broader operating-cost problem, and its weight differs by property type. Until transaction, rental or vacancy data show a measurable effect, claims that the November shootings have repriced South Africa's commercial property market would go beyond the evidence.

Image note: The cover image is AI-generated and illustrative. It does not depict the shootings or a specific commercial property.

#South Africa
#commercial property
#real estate
#security
#tenant survey
#investment
#SAPS

In Summary

What did the tenant survey find?
Among 950 respondents, 8% cited security concerns among their leading premises challenges, compared with 32% for high rental costs and 14% for high operating costs.
Which tenants reported the highest security concerns?
Office tenants reported 14%, followed by industrial tenants at 12% and retail and mixed-use tenants at about 10%.
Does the survey measure crime's effect on property values?
No. It measures tenant concerns and does not quantify changes in property valuations, rents or investment transactions caused by crime.
What should property investors monitor?
Local crime patterns, police response, security and insurance costs, tenant retention, vacancies and comparable property transactions.
AI images used for illustration purposes. All news and stories are factual.
Vukile's KSh76B Deal for 18 Malls Puts Gateway and Cavendish in Play

Up next

african-business

Vukile's KSh76B Deal for 18 Malls Puts Gateway and Cavendish in Play

Vukile has agreed to acquire 18 South African retail properties from Old Mutual, including Gateway and Cavendish Square.

Read next story

More from african-business

See all

Latest from Mwenendo